6. Illustrations and Photos

  • Cleveland Press, March 4, 1908. On this page, a photograph shot from a distance portrays ruins and the effort to fight the fire, but a roughly drawn sketch of smoke, flames, and desperate parents intensifies a feeling of action at the scene.
  • cleveland-news-march6-p9-buschman-mourning2-web

    Cleveland News March 6, 1908. The framing around this portrait of the Buschman sisters suggests a mourning locket to be worn by surviving loved ones.

fancy-divider-520-50px2-webLarge daily newspapers, with their compressed production schedules and massive circulation, had no good way to put photographs on their pages before 1897. Techniques for photographic
reproduction in weekly and monthly publications existed, but the dailies relied on sketch artistsquotation-marks-gray-3-webI don’t believe so many pictures will be required for any great portion of the next century.quotation-marks-gray-closing-3
–Charles Dana, 1894
to capture action and calamity, or simply rejected illustration altogether. Charles A. Dana, editor of the New York Sun, thought visuals distracted from thoughtful text and dismissed them as “a passing fashion.” In a stubborn and failed effort at fortune telling, he told an audience of aspiring journalists at Cornell University in 1894 that “I don’t believe so many pictures will be required for any great portion of the next century.”dagger2-web

As other editors left Dana’s blindered vision behind and turned more and more to photographs, their large and well-established graphics departments resisted. Photography threatened both the employment of illustrators and their status as drawers of journalistic truth.   Readers, they claimed, boston-post-full-headline-illustration-yellow-brown-webThis sketch misrepresents a number of facts, but the view into the building’s interior, cartoon-like men at the door, children leaping, swirling lines of smoke, and packed stairway heighten action more than any surviving photograph.  wanted the art of hand-drawn lines and emotion—not mechanical images infinitely reproduced.camera victorian orange transparent  Newspaper artists failed, of course, to stop the onrushing force of the photograph, but in the coverage of the Collinwood fire, drawn illustrations lingered alongside and even within pictures shot by cameras. Photographs of ruins, street scenes, and bodies dominated visuals of the fire, but vivid diagrams explaining the tragedy also appeared.  Editorial cartoons flourished.camera victorian orange transparent  Artists drew elaborate frames around photographs of the dead; they enhanced photos with line drawings and sketched scenes from imagination that cameras couldn’t shoot. Newspaper illustrators had lost substantial ground to the camera by 1908, but, during this transition in the visual style of the papers, editors and artists still reached for effects that eluded photographers.


Cleveland Press, Mar 7, 1908. A hearse carrying children for burial passes from the sketched foreground to the gritty grayness of the photographic world. Passage of the children’s bodies leaves ghostly abstractions of grief behind it.


  • headline-thumbnail

  • postcards-captionless

    2. Postcards
  • news-on-the-street-reporter-thumbnail-transparent

    3. News on the Street
  • public-square-transparent

    4. Public Square
  • look-of-the-news-transparent

    5. The Look of the News
  • illustrations-red-border

    6. Illustrations
  • information-and-the-fire-transparent

    7. Information
  • glenn-sanderson-transparent

    8. Glenn Sanderson
  • fire-heroines-transparent

    9. Fire Heroines
  • hirter-transparent

    10. Fritz Hirter
  • mourning-transparent

    11. Stereotypes & Sorrow
  • memory-and-witness-transparent

    12. Memory & Witness
  • back-to-home-transparent-web